Direct's fee structure has a hard cliff at $2.49. A repricing rule that treats Direct like marketplace with a different label will misprice everything near that line.
Search for how to price TCGplayer Direct inventory and you'll find one YouTube video and nothing written down. That's a gap, because Direct's fees don't scale the way marketplace fees do, and a pricing rule built for marketplace listings will get the math wrong on a meaningful share of a Direct-enrolled catalog.
Effective June 18, 2026, TCGplayer moved Direct to a per-item fee structure with two completely different fee treatments depending on the card's price:
Commission and Pro fees together are capped at $75 per product, a cap that took effect February 10, 2026.
This is the part a generic repricing rule misses. A card priced at $2.49 and a card priced at $2.50 are not charged similarly with a rounding difference — they're charged under two different fee models entirely.
At $2.49, you pay 50% flat — about $1.25 — and nothing else. At $2.50, you pay $1.12 plus 8.95% commission plus 2.5% transaction, which works out to roughly 56% of the sale price before Pro (about 59% with it) — a heavier fee load than the $2.49 side, not a lighter one, and one that moves at a different rate as price rises.
Below the cliff, your fee is a fixed percentage of price. Above it, a chunk of your fee ($1.12) is fixed regardless of price, so the fee burden as a percentage of price falls as the card gets more expensive, until the $75 cap flattens it again at the high end. That's three different fee curves in one program, depending purely on which side of $2.50 a listing sits.
A rule that discounts off TCG Low, or undercuts a competitor's Direct Low, without checking which side of that line the resulting price lands on, can push a card into a fee structure the seller never intended. A small undercut that drops a card from $2.51 to $2.49 doesn't just shave two cents off the listing — it moves the card from a percentage-based fee to a flat 50% fee, which can be the difference between a normal margin and a loss on the sale.
A marketplace repricing rule optimizes for one thing: staying competitive against other listings at a price the seller can live with. That's still true for Direct, but Direct adds a second constraint the marketplace doesn't have — where the price sits relative to $2.50 changes the entire fee model, not just the fee amount.
Practically, that means:
This is exactly the kind of fee-aware pricing covered more generally in net-margin, fee-aware repricing, and you can run the actual numbers for a specific card through the TCGplayer fees calculator rather than estimating by hand.
Direct eligibility itself is a gate before any of this matters: Level 4 seller status, 99.5% feedback over the trailing 30 days, roughly 3,000 Direct-eligible products, and 100 or more sales a month averaging $600 a week. If you're not enrolled, none of the above changes anything about how you price. If you are, every SKU that's Direct-eligible is running under this fee structure whether your pricing rules account for it or not.
TCGplayer states that more than 95% of Direct sellers see lower fees under the new structure, based on its own comparison of data from February 10 to April 27, 2026. That's TCGplayer's claim about its own program, not an independently verified figure, and it's an aggregate — it doesn't say whether your specific mix of sub-$2.49 and higher-value inventory comes out ahead. That depends on where your catalog sits relative to $2.50, not on the headline percentage.
Don't run one rule across marketplace and Direct inventory. Build the Direct-eligible portion of your catalog as its own segment, price it against the correct fee curve for each side of the $2.49 line, and re-check any card that a rule is about to move across that line — the fee model on either side isn't a small difference, it's a different formula. Hoard's repricing agent treats Direct-enrolled SKUs as a separate fee context rather than applying marketplace assumptions to them; see how the repricing agent works for the mechanics.
Connect your TCGplayer store and see which Direct listings sit right on the $2.49 line before a rule moves them across it.
Get started free