TCG Sync is a full commerce platform: ten sales channels, a hosted storefront, and a TCGplayer sync layer built into the setup. Hoard is a repricing agent that bolts onto the TCGplayer store a seller already runs. The question is whether the platform is worth the setup cost, or whether a seller only needs the sync piece.
TCG Sync sells three things at once: a hosted storefront, a point-of-sale layer, and synchronized listings across ten channels (TCGplayer, Cardmarket, eBay, Cardtrader, Mana Pool, CardSynced, Shopify, Whatnot, TikTok Shop, and Amazon). Hoard sells one thing: automated TCGplayer repricing, running against the TCGplayer store a seller already has. Comparing them fairly means being clear about which layer each one actually operates on.
If a seller wants to sell the same inventory across ten different channels from one system, TCG Sync has the widest channel coverage found anywhere in this research. No other platform covered here, Hoard included, reaches TikTok Shop, Whatnot, Cardtrader, and Amazon from a single sync layer. That breadth is a real, structural advantage for any seller trying to consolidate a multi-channel operation into one back office.
TCG Sync also claims its TCGplayer sync runs with "no API credentials, no scraping, no Chrome extensions." That's a specific technical claim from TCG Sync's own marketing that we haven't independently verified, so treat it as their description of the mechanism rather than a confirmed fact.
Separately from the product itself: TCG Sync is, by this research, the SEO leader across this entire tool category, and it currently owns the "BinderPOS going dark" narrative uncontested. It's the result most sellers searching for a BinderPOS replacement will find first. That's a real competitive strength worth naming plainly, not a footnote.
Hoard doesn't ask a seller to move their storefront anywhere. There's no new hosted store, no POS migration, no re-platforming ten channels' worth of listings. A seller connects their existing TCGplayer account, and automated repricing starts running against inventory that's already live, on TCGplayer's own storefront.
That distinction matters most at the pricing tier. TCG Sync's vendor-only plan is £14.99/mo (£149.99/yr), reasonable on its own, but Storefront Pro, the tier that actually runs the hosted commerce platform, carries a £1,000 setup fee plus 2% on TCG singles and sealed sales. Enterprise runs £25,000/yr or £2,499/mo, though at 0% transaction fee. Hoard has no setup wall at any tier and prices flat by sync frequency, not as a percentage of sales. See Hoard's plans.
The real limit: TCG Sync's ten-channel reach is real, and Hoard doesn't match it. Hoard doesn't sync to Cardmarket, eBay, Shopify, Whatnot, TikTok Shop, or Amazon today. Hoard's depth is narrower and specific: TCGplayer-native automated repricing, with floors, ceilings, and a decision log for every price change. A seller who genuinely needs ten channels in one system has a real reason to choose TCG Sync. A seller who sells on TCGplayer and wants pricing handled without a platform migration has a real reason to choose Hoard.
| Feature | TCG Sync | Hoard |
|---|---|---|
| Sales channels synced | 10 (TCGplayer, Cardmarket, eBay, Cardtrader, Mana Pool, CardSynced, Shopify, Whatnot, TikTok Shop, Amazon) | TCGplayer only |
| Requires new hosted storefront | Yes, for Storefront Pro | No — bolts onto existing TCGplayer store |
| Setup fee | £1,000 (Storefront Pro) | None |
| Entry pricing | £14.99/mo vendor-only, £149.99/yr | Flat monthly by sync tier |
| Transaction fee | 2% on TCG singles/sealed (Storefront Pro); 0% on Enterprise | 0% — flat fee only |
| Automated TCGplayer repricing | Sync-focused, not a dedicated repricing engine | Yes — scheduled, with floors, ceilings, and receipts |
| Non-Magic market coverage | Not specified | All 25 TCGplayer-supported games |
Storefront Pro's setup cost pays for standing up a full commerce platform (a hosted storefront, POS integration, and cross-channel sync), which is a fair price for that scope of work. It isn't a fair comparison point against a tool that only does repricing, because Hoard isn't trying to replace the storefront at all. A seller evaluating the two should be clear with themselves about which one they're actually buying: a new platform, or a pricing layer on top of the one they already run.
The Enterprise tier's 0% fee at £25,000/yr makes sense at real scale, where percentage-based pricing would cost more than a flat annual number. For a seller who isn't at that scale yet, the Storefront Pro middle tier is where the setup fee and the 2% both apply at once.
A seller selling exclusively through TCGplayer, with no near-term plan to add Cardmarket, eBay, or Whatnot, is paying for nine channels they won't use if they go with Storefront Pro. Connect a TCGplayer store and see what Hoard finds before deciding whether the platform migration is worth it — there's no setup fee to evaluate against.
Comparing TCG Sync's channel breadth against Storepass's enterprise safety features instead? TCG Sync vs. Storepass runs that scorecard directly.
No new storefront, no setup fee, no percentage of sales. Connect your existing TCGplayer store and see the read before anything changes.
Get started free